A continuous freeze crystallization process for separating organics from water

Researchers from Wageningen University and Research, Wetsus – European centre of excellence for sustainable water technology, and Cool Separations BV have just published a new technique for separating lactose from whey permeate by partly freezing it in Food Research International magazine. This highly efficient method can recover a continuous stream of organic material from a liquid solution. And it does so at a fraction of the energy cost, preserving flavours, and with little chance of biological activity and fouling, scaling, and corrosion issues.

With this publication, the scientists have proven the workings of the pilot-scale application of eutectic freeze crystallization (EFC) for separating organics from a watery solution. With this method a solution is simultaneously converted in crystals and ice. Lactose is industrially recovered by first concentrating it by evaporation and then slowly cooling this solution to produce the crystals. This is a very energy intense process; a state-of-the-art evaporator costs 30 to 80% more energy to run than than EFC. And EFC can continuously produce 60 kilograms of highly pure ice and 16 kg of lactose per hour. Building from this conceptual design, yields of at least 80% and up to 95% of the input lactose can be achieved.

Though previously EFC was mainly used on brines, this study makes a strong point for its use in the food and agricultural industry for compounds such as sugars. Because it works by freezing water while crystallizing the desired compounds, it is ideal for food application – heat-sensitive compounds are unaffected and preserve taste and quality. Another big plus: biological activity is low, and fouling, scaling, and corrosion issues will be less prominent at temperatures below zero.

The mechanic is the result of an exemplary PhD study. “It is a great case of how close collaboration can lead to actual innovation,” says Wetsus’ theme coordinator Dr. Henk Miedema. The main author and PhD candidate Ruben Halfwerk showed that there is certainly potential for EFC in the food industry. In four years’ time Wetsus developed the EFC process for lactose from lab to pilot scale. The next step would be to further develop and optimize the process and to look into other streams in the agro- and food industry. 

For more information:
please contact Wetsus’ science communication specialist Rouèl Gnodde;; +058 284 3158 /+31 6 51 879 000

Read more:

Halfwerk, R., L. Verdonk, D. Yntema, J. van Spronsen, A. van der Padt. 2023. “Scaling up Continuous Eutectic Freeze Crystallization of Lactose from Whey Permeate: A Pilot Plant Study at Sub-Zero Temperatures.” Food Research International (Ottawa, Ont.) 168 (112764): 112764.

Read more:

Towards an economy of value preservation | By Niels Faber


The realisation of a circular economy has thus far unfolded under the assumption that it would fit within existing economic arrangements. In practice, we witness many circular initiatives struggling to give shape to their ambitions, let alone develop to maturity. These past months, various material recycling organisations terminated their activities, seeing virgin alternatives from other parts of the world flooding the market at prices against they cannot compete. If the transition towards a circular economy (i.e. an economy of value preservation) is to be taken seriously, a new perspective on value in our economic system seems unavoidable, as the rewriting of the rules of the economic game. At this moment, current perceptions of value stand in the way of this transition both at micro as well as macro levels. Several contours for a collective exploration of new directions of value and economic configuration that foster circular transition will be addressed.

Searching Innovation for the Common Good | By Cees Buisman


In his key note he will conclude after a life of innovations that it is impossible that humanity will stay within the save planetary boundaries with innovation only. We should be more critical about the behaviour of the rich population in the world and more critical about new innovations that prove to be dangerous, like the PFAS crisis shows at this moment. In his keynote he will investigate how to look at the world that can stay within the save planetary boundaries, how should we change ourselves? It is clear if we only talk about the words of science and systems we miss the essential words of how we should cooperate and change ourselves. And his search for coherent save innovations. Which innovations will be save and will lead to a fair and sustainable world? And will lead to a world we want to live in.

Future-fit economic models: What do they have in common – how can they join forces? | By Christian Felber


There is a growing number of new sustainable, inclusive, cohesive, participatory, just and humane economic models. A possible next step in the discourse about them is the comparative analysis in order to find out key commonalities, potential synergies, and “requirements” for a future-fit economic model. The author and initiator of the Economy for the Common Good provides an overview of these „new sustainable economic models“ and compares them according to underlying values, principles, and practical ways of implementation. The keynote addresses the cooperative spirit of the conference and prepares the ground for its public highlight on the eve of June 3rd, the round table with representatives of diverse future-fit economic models.

The era of postgrowth economics | By Matthias Olthaar


The scientific debate on whether economies should always continue to grow increasingly becomes a political and societal debate. On the one hand further growth for the most affluent countries seems neither possible nor valuable, but on the other hand there is still lack of understanding and knowledge what a non-growing economy should look like and could best be governed. In this lecture we discuss various policy measures that can be realistically implemented, take into account government finances and aim at a higher quality of life despite a non-growing economy.

Democratic principles for a sustainable economy | By Lisa Herzog


Democracy is under pressure, and less and less able to stir the economy into a sustainable direction. Therefore, to stabilize democracy and to make possible the socio-ecological transformation of the economy, democratic principles need to be implemented directly in the economy. This is not only a matter of morality, but also has practical advantages. Democratizing the economy can increase legitimacy and take advantage of the “knowledge of the many” to accelerate the transformation. Democratic practices, especially deliberation, allow bringing together different forms of knowledge, which is crucial for the local implementation of principles of social and ecological sustainability. This talk explores what this idea means in more concrete terms, from democratic participation in the workplace to the democratization of time.

Market, state, association, and well-being. An historical approach | By Bas van Bavel


Over the past decades, markets have conventionally been seen as the best instrument to stimulate economic growth and enhance prosperity and well-being. The automatic link between markets and economic growth is increasingly questioned, however, as well as the automatic link between economic growth and enhancement of well-being. This has led to attempts to capture well-being development more directly than through GDP per capita figures and has produced a more variegated picture of well-being growth. Also, this has led to a shift of focus to other coordination systems than the market, as primarily the state but increasingly also the association. Analyses of the historical record suggest that especially the latter could be a vital component in future well-being.